M: Pimento cheese is kind of a big deal here in the North Carolina. So much so, that locals are often surprised to hear that not only is it not a staple outside of the South, but many Northerners haven’t even heard of it. I’ve read that its popularity has spread in recent years (last year Bon Appetit declared it the hot food trend for 2011), but you ain’t got nothing on North Carolina’s dedication to the lightly spiced blend of cheese, mayonnaise, and pimento peppers.
With its origins right here in the NC piedmont in the early 1900s, it was considered a delicacy, served primarily in finger sandwich form. As its popularity grew, pimento peppers became a more commonly grown crop, lowering the cost and allowing the spread to develop into a food for the masses. Still popular in finger sandwich form, it is also enjoyed as a cracker spread, a topping for hot dogs or hamburgers and a go-to for a quick bite in sandwich form, both cold and grilled. Of course, as with seemingly all Southern staples, many restaurants have taken creative liberties, including it on menus as a nacho topping, rolled in bread crumbs and deep fried, used as a base for cheese straws and even served in pimento cheese cake.
As many twists on the standard as there are, pimento cheese remains a home made favorite. Practically anybody you ask here will either talk about their cherished family recipe or tell you whose pimento cheese you need to try, because it is the best you’ll ever have. In my office, that honor went to Beverly for quite a while. She doesn’t work there anymore, but I still consider tracking her down.
As coveted as pimento cheese is here, this is the first time I’ve actually made it. What better place to start than with this Blue Ribbon recipe? It earns the title. Pimento cheese is a simple concoction made special with varied blends of spices. Everyone has their own perfect blend and this balances out very nicely. Left to my own devices, I might add a bit of cumin to the mix, but it does quite well as published. I wonder how it would stack up against Beverly’s.
What I like best about this recipe, though, is the author’s insistence that if you’re not going to make the mayo from scratch, you may as well not bother. My partner here at the Skillet taught me how to make mayonnaise nearly a decade ago and I haven’t bought a jar since. Even if you don’t try this pimento cheese recipe, if you’ve never done it, whip up some homemade mayonnaise. It’s easy, it’s magic and it makes a humble condiment something special.
Recipe: Blue Ribbon Pimento Cheese
Summary: A versatile North Carolina favorite welcome at tea party, picnic or kitchen table. From The Southern Foodways Alliance Community Cookbook.
Ingredients
- 20 oz Cheddar Cheese, grated (about 5 c)
- 1 (4 oz) Jar Whole Pimentos, drained
- 1/2 to 1 c Lella’s Mayonnaise (recipe below)
- 1/4 tsp Onion Powder
- 1/4 tsp Ground Cayenne Pepper
- 1/4 tsp Worcestershire Sauce
- Pinch Sugar
Instructions
- Pulse cheese and pimentos in a food processor until pimentos are finely chopped.
- Add 1/2 c mayonnaise and pulse to combine.
- Add onion powder, cayenne, Worcestershire and sugar and pulse to mix until smooth. (color should be uniform and consistency should be that of thick paste).
- If too dry, add mayonnaise until desired texture is reached.
Recipe: Lella’s Mayonnaise
Ingredients
- 1 Large Egg
- 1 c Vegetable Oil
- 1/2 tsp Dry Mustard
- 1/4 tsp Onion Powder
- Pinch Cayenne Pepper
- 1/2 tsp Salt
- 1 T Fresh Lemon Juice
Instructions*
- Place egg, 1/4 c oil, mustard, onion powder, cayenne, salt and lemon juice in food processor.
- With processor running, slowly add remaining oil until mayonnaise is thick.
*M: I prepare mayonnaise by placing all ingredients except oil in a mason jar. Inserting a stick blender, slowly add oil while blending until thick. Pop a lid on the jar and it is ready for the fridge. No muss, no fuss.





